I meant to post this more than a week ago, but I got distracted by, well, laziness. Ha ha! Oops!
Any person who grows up in New Jersey is obligated to like tomatoes as soon as he or she has teeth. If there’s one thing - one good thing, I should say - that Jersey is famous for, it’s the tomatoes. Somehow, even despite the fact that my mother used to grow them in the back yard, I didn’t grow up liking tomatoes, which is probably why I was exiled at the age of twelve, forced to strike out as a nomad until I finished receiving my high school education from random hobos on trains, at which point I was allowed back in only after eating a dozen tomatoes while reciting Who’s On First set to Bruce Springsteen songs.
Making a good stuffed tomato can be difficult, because the tendency will be to end up with a mushy, sloppy mess that only barely resembles the dish’s constituent parts. I’ve taken quite a few tricks from Alton Brown’s stuffed tomato recipe that result in a firm, slightly crunchy tomato, and in fact plagiarized that recipe so blatantly that I actually feel a little guilty. So, thanks and kudos to Alton Brown.
I’m making a lot of tomatoes here. Remember that I usually cook enough food to keep myself fed for an entire week. Don’t feel bad if you can’t handle the magnitude.
So, start with eight large tomatoes. The ones that I had were about halfway between baseball and softball sized. You’ll also need 2 cups of finely chopped mushrooms; 2 finely diced medium yellow onions; a few finely diced cloves of garlic; about a pound of ground beef; five or six slices of bacon; some bleu cheese (I was using the leftover from the steak I had made a couple days before); grated mozzarella cheese; 1/2 cup of cheap whiskey (you can use 1 cup of red or white wine instead, if you want); and salt and pepper.
Start by microwaving the bacon on high until crunchy (that is, not just crispy). Every microwave is different, so the time this takes will vary. My microwave took about fifteen minutes. Just leave it running until you don’t hear any more popping. Don’t worry about it if you burn the bacon.
While the bacon cooks, slice off the top of and core each tomato. If you don’t have a really sharp knife, odds are good that the blade edge won’t catch on the tomato’s smooth, tough skin, and you’ll slip and cut yourself. To prevent this, use a bread knife.
As for coring, start by reaching a finger into each of the little chambers on the inside of the tomato and digging out all of the jelly inside. If there are any cuts on your finger that you aren’t yet aware of, this is where you’ll find out about them. That jelly is very acidic. I got a tiny cut on my left ring finger as I was cutting the tomatoes, and even that was torture. After you finish third-basing the tomato, use a grapefruit spoon to dig out the pink core, leaving only the red, outer wall of the tomato.
Sprinkle the inside of each tomato liberally with salt and place upside down on a rack in the sink to drain. The salt will draw the moisture out from the inside of the tomato meat. By getting all of that water out now, we prevent it from soaking into the stuffing later and making everything all sloppy and gross.
While the tomatoes drain, we can work on the stuffing. Saute the garlic and onions in olive oil on medium heat until the onions are softened and translucent. Add the mushrooms, salt them, and cook for a few more minutes until the liquid has boiled off. Add whiskey and cook until most of it is absorbed or evaporated. Few things smell as good as mushrooms cooking in whiskey. Finally, add the ground beef along with some salt and pepper, and cook until brown. Turn off the heat, crumble in the cooked bacon, and mix everything up.
Postscript to that: I felt like making the stuffing a little spicier this time, just for the hell of it. When I want to make something spicy, ground coriander seed (as opposed to coriander, which is actually known as cilantro in North America) is usually where I turn first. I find it to be nice and spicy, without causing flaming hell death like red pepper does, and I like the hint of citrus it has to it. It’s one of the main ingredients in many versions of curry, so if you don’t like curry, you won’t like coriander. In that case, just use a lot of pepper or maybe a diced jalapeno.
Preheat your broiler on high.
Stuff each tomato, and then top each one with a layer mozzarella, followed by a layer of bleu cheese. When stuffing the tomatoes, make sure to leave a little room at the top so you can add the cheese without it falling over the sides of the tomatoes. Also, don’t go too crazy with the bleu cheese, because bleu has a tendency to overpower everything.
Eat the leftover stuffing. It’s sooooo good.
Place the stuffed tomatoes on a baking sheet and place in the broiler for a few minutes, until the cheese is melted and golden brown. It should only take two or three minutes. Leave the door cracked open so you can keep an eye on the cheese, and so the broiler doesn’t turn off.
Let them sit for a few minutes so the heat in the stuffing and cheese can transfer into the tomatoes a little more evenly. They shouldn’t be too hot to touch, so you could probably get away with serving them as really messy finger food if you want. I’m sure it will be just fine so long as you’re outside or you have a dog.
Ingredients:
8 large tomatoes, cored and seeded
2 cups finely chopped mushrooms
2 medium yellow onions, finely diced
3 or 4 cloves garlic, finely diced
1 lb. ground beef
5 or 6 slices bacon
Grated mozarella cheese
Grated bleu cheese
1/2 cup whiskey (or 1 cup red or white wine)
1 tbsp. olive oil
Salt and pepper
Microwave bacon on high until crunchy.
Sprinkle the insides of the tomatoes with salt and place upside down to drain.
Saute garlic and onion in olive oil over medium heat until translucent. Add mushrooms and cook for five minutes. Add whiskey and cook until most of the liquid is gone. Add ground beef and cook until brown. Turn off the heat, crumble in the cooked bacon, and mix everything up.
Preheat broiler on high. Stuff the tomatoes, and then sprinkle with grated mozzarella, followed by bleu cheese.
Place tomatoes on a baking sheet and place under the broiler for 3 minutes, or until the cheese is melted and golden brown.
Background music was Led Zeppelin III and Foo Fighters’ In Your Honor, Disc 1. Tomatoes like to rock out, you see.
Microwavability: 3/5 - The flavor won’t be affected by the microwave at all, but there’s a good chance that the tomato will get squishy and leak juice everywhere, no matter how well you drained them before. I don’t mind it, personally, but if you do, just eat some rice with it to soak up the mess.
Watch Ray Cook A Thing Add Comment »